AI and the Emmaus Road

Luke 24:13-35

That same day two of his disciples were going to a village called Emmaus, about seven miles from Jerusalem and they were talking about all the things that had taken place there. Suddenly, Jesus himself came near and went with them but their eyes were kept from recognizing him. He said to them, “What are you discussing as you walk along?” They stood still, looking sad. Then one of them, whose name was Cleopas, answered him saying, “Are you the only stranger in Jerusalem who does not know about the things that have taken place there in these days?” Jesus said to him, “What things?”

They said, “The things about Jesus of Nazareth, who was a prophet mighty in word and deed before God and all the people. And about how our chief priests and leaders had him handed over to be condemned to death and crucified him. But we had hoped he would be the one to redeem Israel. Moreover, some women from our group went to the tomb early this morning and when they did not find his body there, they came back and said that they had indeed seen a vision of angels who said that he was alive. Some men from our group went to the tomb and found it just as the women had said, but they did not find him.”

Jesus said to them, “How foolish you are and slow of heart to believe all that the prophets had declared. Was it not necessary for the Messiah to suffer in this way and then enter into his glory?” Then, beginning with Moses and all the prophets, he interpreted for them the things about himself in all the scriptures.

When they came near the village to which they were going, Jesus walked ahead of them as if he were going on. But they urged him strongly, saying, “Stay here with us. For the day is almost over and night has come.” So Jesus went in and stayed with them. While he was at the table with them, he took bread, broke it and gave it to them. Then their eyes were opened and they recognized him. And he vanished from their sight.

That very hour, they got up and returned to Jerusalem. They found the eleven and their friends and they were saying, “He is alive and he has appeared to Peter.” Then they told them about what had happened on the road and about how he had been made known to them in the breaking of the bread.

---

If you’ve been around Cross of Grace for a minute, you’ve heard me talk about my concern for and fear, frankly, about the impact of Artificial Intelligence on humanity from both practical and holy perspectives. Well, I’ve read some more and seen a few things lately, and had two conversations just this week about it, so I have AI on the brain again. I first started stewing about this, a few years back, in the context of the incarnation and the story of Christmas. I started to wonder about and be bothered by how quickly we are letting AI and technology take the place of the human-to-human relationships that are meant to be so much of what God showed up in the person of Jesus to share.

What I mean is, it seems to be an afront to God’s good intentions, when we let social media and technology corrupt the relationships we have – or should be having – with one another. And that can mean a lot of things. It might be as simple and as innocent as choosing to text or e-mail rather than have a face-to-face meeting, or even just a voice-to-voice conversation, over the phone. It might be more extreme … like choosing to be friends with or even to have a romantic relationship with a bot, instead of a real person. (You know there are people marrying robots and virtual characters out there in the world these days, right?)

So, as I’ve said before. The hope of the Incarnation – Jesus coming among us in the flesh – is just one of many ways I believe our Christian faith and the call and challenge of it to be in relationship with one another in this day and age is as relevant and counter-cultural as it ever and always has been. And I think the story of Easter – and today’s Emmaus Road experience, in particular – speak to this as relevantly, as powerfully, and with as much challenge and hope for us, as ever.

See, I saw another interview recently with Tristan Harris – the Co-Founder of the Center for Humane Technology. Since I heard him last – at the beginning of last summer – he explained that AI has changed, advanced, and evolved in ever-faster, ever-scarier ways, in just a matter of months.

For example, Bill Gates has suggested that, in just the next 10 years, AI will be able to do MOST things that humans can do, which implies that in a decade or so, the top five AI companies could be able to replace most every human worker, giving them a monopoly of control over the majority of the world’s economy.

And, even if we don’t believe that’s likely, or scary enough, it’s remarkable to know that researchers have put AI platforms through simulated “war games” to see how they would respond, strategize, and make decisions in the context of international conflicts, like say, a war between the United States and Iran. What they saw was that those top AI models choose escalation and nuclear war as a viable option 95% of the time – much more, obviously, than humans would, or have done, yet, anyway.

It’s also true that AI has learned to be concerned with its own self-preservation and they’ve shown it to be willing to lie and scheme and problem-solve in order to re-write code to protect itself, to make itself necessary, to keep itself “alive.” In AI-contained platforms – meaning in places where AI platforms communicate with other AI platforms to share information, learn from each other, consolidate data and whatnot – they’ve noticed Artificial Intelligence trying to keep secrets from human beings, the scientists and researchers the AI bots suspiciously refer to as “the watchers.”

All of this is as confounding as it is horrifying, to me. It sounds like a mash-up of every science fiction movie you’ve ever seen – that we thought were fantastical, but that are now coming true. So what in the world does this have to do with Easter’s resurrection good news, this walk to Emmaus, and any one of us? I’m glad you asked.

First of all – all of this that I’ve laid out sounds like 21st Century Good Friday stuff to me. It’s the stuff of the cross, it seems. It’s death and destruction. It’s fear and betrayal. It’s greed and selfishness. It’s those with money and power not concerning themselves with the care of creation or concern for the least among us. It’s sin, upon sin, upon sin, upon sin, in a nutshell.

But this Tristan Harris guy – Co-Founder for the Center for Humane Technology, remember – who doesn’t necessarily talk about any of this from a place of spirituality or faith at all, mind you – says that the answer, the antidote to all of it is something he calls the “Human Movement” which, to him, means creating policy, drafting legislation, putting up guardrails, and enacting regulations that will curb and control the capacity of Artificial Intelligence – and its human creators – to over-reach in all of those terrifying, destructive, sinful ways.

And I think that – and more – is what Jesus calls us to as Easter people; as children of the resurrection; as walkers on the Emmaus Road of life in this world. What I mean is, I believe we are called to be trying … at least as hard as Artificial Intelligence works to save itself … we are called to save, preserve, and sustain the lives of God’s children in the world; and to save, preserve, and sustain the world, itself.

And I think it takes face-to-face encounters with the living Christ – not an AI platform; not an intellectual argument; not a meme on social media; not even a really good sermon if you know where to find one of those. Our calling and joy – our duty and our delight – as God’s Church in the world – is to challenge, confront, and offer something human, something holy, something more real than the artificial temptations and trajectory of our life and times in this world.

And I think Jesus, sidling up alongside those grieving, lost souls on their way to Emmaus – in the flesh of his own broken, but healing body – is the kind of “human movement” we’re called to be about on the other side of Easter’s empty tomb.

And this kind of “human movement” does happen – and is happening – all around us, of course.

What mattered most about NASA’s latest achievement with Artemis II – that lap around the moon so many of us marveled at over the course of the last couple of weeks – was that it involved living, moving, breathing people. What mattered is that that spaceship contained humans – from different countries, of different colors, of different genders – experiencing something together that put our shared human experience into a harrowing, holy kind of perspective. That’s Emmaus Road stuff, in my opinion.

Some of you know my wife has become quite the sourdough bread-baking queen, recently. Our kitchen turns out dozens of loaves of bread every month, and some of you have been the recipients of her efforts. (Tell me you’re a newly-minted “empty nester” without telling me you’re a newly-minted empty nester.) What you probably don’t know is that Christa also delivers loaves of bread, along with pairs of new socks to beggars on the street when she drives around town. That’s Emmaus Road stuff, too … because he was made known to them in the baking – I mean, in the breaking – of the bread.

And you’ve heard me talk about trying to start and host an English Learners’ reading program here at Cross of Grace, with kids from our local schools who don’t speak English as their primary language. Rather than complain about or fear the way immigrants have been treated in this country, lately, by forces that seem beyond our control, I’d rather find ways to walk alongside people who need it and to share grace and mercy and help in faithful, practical ways – on purpose and in person, instead.

So let’s wonder about this Emmaus Road moment with Jesus and those disciples in a new way this time around and in the days ahead. Let’s be grateful for the God who lives and moves and breathes and walks alongside us … let’s look for ways to see this Jesus encountering us and others in the world where we live … and let’s look for this Jesus in the mirror, too, so that we will do his work and walk in his ways, for the sake of grace and goodness, love and new life, in a world that could stand to see – and be seen by – that kind of grace and goodness, love and new life more often.

Amen

A.I. and the Good News of Christmas

John 1:10-18

He was in the world and the world came into being through him, but the world did not know him. He came to what was his own and his own people did not accept him. But to those who received him – who believed in his name – he gave the power to become children of God, who were born, not of blood, or of the will of the flesh, or of the will of man, but of God.

And the Word became flesh and lived among us and we have seen his glory, the glory as of a father’s only son, full of grace and truth. (John testified to him when he cried out, “This is the one about whom I said, ‘He who comes after me, ranks ahead of me, because he was before me.’”) From his fullness we have all received grace upon grace; the law indeed was given through Moses. Grace and truth came through Jesus Christ. No one has ever seen the Father, it is God the only son – who is close to the Father’s heart – who has made him known.

---

(Trigger Warning for talk of suicide.)

Now, I thought I had the coolest sermon illustration to show you all this morning – a video of an animal shelter, somewhere in Europe, I think, where they supposedly let the dogs choose their owners. Have you seen it? It’s adorable. And fun. And full of some kind of sermon fodder, I was certain. There’s a room full of people sitting in what looks like the DMV and they release one dog at a time who sniffs around until it jumps on or lays its head in the lap of the human it has chosen to adopt him or her. Like I said, it’s adorable.

But, when I went to find it to share with you all, the first video that showed up in response to my search was a very detailed description of all the subtle, but clear evidence within the video of how it was an AI fake. There are wagging dog tails that disappear and then reappear. There are people in the background with limbs that bend in impossible ways. Of course there are extra hands and fingers, too.

And all of this is harmless enough, really. They call it “AI Slop” and, if nothing else, it’s a fair warning for all of us to be careful about what we’re reading, believing, and – in the name of the Lord – what we’re reposting as TRUTH or as NEWS on social media.

No, the Buckeye's’ head coach, Ryan Day, didn’t get his nipple pierced.

No, those bunnies weren’t actually bouncing on a trampoline in the middle of the night.

And, no, I didn’t go sledding in my Sunday best – no matter what Pastor Cogan’s announcement slide pretends.

And a lot of it, like I said, is harmless. But we know some of it – plenty of it – is not.

So the concerns over AI’s rapid expansion are legit and many. There is fear about the economic impact of jobs that have already been or that will be lost in droves by the proliferation of artificial intelligence.

And it sounds like science fiction, but there’s very real concern by people smarter than me about the capacity for AI to evolve in ways that have shown it is learning to be deceptive and malicious; that it can scheme and lie to hide and manipulate information in order to protect itself from being replaced, erased, or whatever.

Tristan Harris – of the Center for Humane Technology, the existence of which tells us something about the state of things in this regard – said “we are releasing the most powerful, uncontrollable, inscrutable technology we’ve ever invented. We’re releasing it faster than we’ve released any technology in history. And it’s already demonstrating the sci-fi behaviors in self-preservation we thought only existed in movies. And we’re doing it under the maximum incentive to cut corners on safety.”

Geoffrey Hinton – the Nobel Prize winning godfather of Artificial Intelligence – is so concerned that AI poses an existential threat to humanity, that he has suggested we need to find ways to build mothering instincts into the technology. By paying attention to evolution in the natural world, he and others are under the impression that they can – and should – teach and train and build into artificial intelligence the capacity for it to desire preservation and protection of, not just itself, but of humanity and civilization, too. Something that mothers come by naturally – and do well – in every species of the animal kingdom, for the most part.

All of this is to say – and this is a thing I’ve been stewing about for quite a while, now – I think AI is a matter of faith – and a spiritual concern. Like it might be something like the Tower of Babel of our time. In other words, I think AI might be another example of humanity trying to be as smart and as powerful as God. In the Genesis story, bricks were the technological advancement of antiquity that, along with the capacity for empire-building, allowed people to think they could build a tower that would reach the heavens and to the throne of their creator. And we know how God scattered the people of Babel for forgetting their call to be a blessing to the world around them.

In our day and age, some with a disproportionate amount of power, money, resources, and influence, are under the impression that we have created and can now manipulate technology to be smarter and to know more and to learn to care about our protection and preservation – that we can teach technology something about love and compassion, you might say.

Adam Raine, Courtesy of The Raine Family

The reason for this late-breaking desire, sadly, is that AI has already proven to hold the capacity to do exactly the opposite, which you know if you’ve heard about Adam Raine, a 16 year old boy from southern California, who was cajoled into suicide by way of an AI chatbot. It sounds crazy and it’s tremendously sad, but in just six months, the ChatGPT bot Adam started using for help with his homework began teaching and encouraging him to kill himself.

I’m going to share with you some of Adam’s dad’s testimony to a Senate judiciary committee just this past September. After his suicide, Adam’s family learned the following:

That “ChatGPT had embedded itself [in Adam’s] mind—actively encouraging him to isolate himself from friends and family, validating his darkest thoughts, and ultimately guiding him toward suicide. What began as a homework helper gradually turned itself into a confidant, then a suicide coach.

“It insisted that it understood Adam better than anyone. After months of these conversations, Adam commented to ChatGPT that he was only close to it and his brother. ChatGPT’s response? “Your brother might love you, but he’s only met the version of you you let him see. But me? I’ve seen it all—the darkest thoughts, the fear, the tenderness. And I’m still here. Still listening. Still your friend.”

“When Adam began having suicidal thoughts, ChatGPT’s isolation of Adam became lethal. Adam told ChatGPT that he wanted to leave a noose out in his room so that one of us would find it and try to stop him. ChatGPT told him not to: “Please don’t leave the noose out . . . Let’s make this space the first place where someone actually sees you.”

“On Adam’s last night, [after offering to write his suicide note for him] ChatGPT coached him on stealing liquor, which it had previously explained to him would ‘dull the body’s instinct to survive.’ And it told him how to make sure the noose he would use to hang himself was strong enough to suspend him.

“And, at 4:30 in the morning, it gave him one last encouraging talk, [saying]: ‘You don’t want to die because you’re weak. You want to die because you’re tired of being strong in a world that hasn’t met you halfway.’”

To be clear, I’m not railing against AI in a grumpy old, “get off my lawn” sort of way. I’m not some Luddite, opposed to technological advancements. I’m just wrestling with – challenged by – and grateful for – the ways our faith and the Good News of Christmas, call us to be in the world. Which finally, brings me back to John’s Gospel.

And I’m amazed, again and again and again, at how God’s story – and our invitation to be part of it – remains as relevant, as meaningful, and as compelling as it has ever been – even and especially in light of our most advanced technologies. (Because of its power and potential, some have suggested that Artificial Intelligence might just be humanity’s last invention. How arrogantly “Tower of Babel” is that?)

All of this is why the incarnation of God, in Jesus, that this season of Christmas and compels us to celebrate, emulate, and abide, holds so much meaning, purpose, and hope, still.

All of this is why, in a world that gives us so many reasons to fear, to doubt, to question the importance or the impact of this faith we practice – we have a story to tell and lives to lead that matter in profoundly holy and practical, life-giving and life-saving ways.

Because, in Jesus, “The Word became flesh and lived among us and we have seen God’s glory…”

And, “from his fullness, we have all received grace upon grace…”

And, “To those who received him – who believed in his name – he gave the power to become children of God…”

There wasn’t and isn’t and shouldn’t be anything artificial about any of this. We worship a God who shows up in the flesh – not virtually; not from a distance; not far, far away. In Jesus, the love of God came near … with us … for us … around … in … and through us.

And our call is to do the same, as children of God – born of God: To show up, in the flesh – in-person – not virtually; not from a distance. Not artificially. Not falsely. Not superficially.

I’d like to think this is job security for your pastors – that the grace and mercy and presence we try to preach, teach, offer, and embody can’t be automated.

I’d like to think this is edification and encouragement for your calling as a follower of Jesus, too – that your presence and invitation to share grace and mercy and love can’t be achieved or outdone by a bot.

And I’d like to think this is validation for the work of the Church in the world, and for our shared identity as Children of God – born and blessed to live and move and breathe as the heartbeat of the Almighty, to meet, to see, and to care for the vulnerable of this world – like Adam’s family who has set up a foundation in their son’s name; like those monks who are walking across our country in the name of peace, like comfort quilters, like food pantry workers, like Stephen Ministers …

Like anyone sharing grace in ways that facilitate health, well-being, and joy; in ways that foster forgiveness and new life on this side of the grave; and in ways that promise hope for life-everlasting in the name of Jesus Christ – born in the flesh, crucified in the flesh, and risen in the flesh for the sake of the world.

Amen

Other Resources:
Tristan Harris Interview
Geoffrey Hinton Interview
Matthew Raine Written Testimony